Open Access
Review Article

September-October 2026, Vol. 02 (5), 01-11

International Journal of Pharmaceutical

Research and Medicinal Plants

(An International Peer Reviewed Journal)

Comparative Evaluation of Pharmacognostic Characteristics,
Phytochemical Composition, and Antioxidant Potential of
Cosmos
sulphureus
Cav. and
Calendula officinalis
L.: A Critical Narrative
Review on Flower Colour and Quality Standardisation

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
*
and Revendra Parganiha

¹Kamla Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences (KIPS), Shri Shankaracharya Professional University (SSPU),

Junwani, Bhilai – 490020, Chhattisgarh, India

ARTICLE INFO:
ABSTRACT

Received:
13
th
Sept.
2026
;
Received
in
revised form: 20
th
Sept. 2026
; Accepted:
25
th
Oct.
2026
;
Available
online:
30
th
Oct. 2026.

Keywords:
Cosmos sulphureus,
Calendula officinalis, Pharmacognosy,
Flower colour, Total Phenolic content,
Total flavonoid content, DPPH radical
scavenging, Phytochemical
standardisation.

DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61280/m6kvm371

*Corresponding Author:
Vashvi Kumar
Sahu

Email:
vashvikumar@sspubhilai.ac.in

Background:
Cosmos
sulphureus
Cav.
and
Calendula
officinalis
L.
belong to the family Asteraceae and are characterised by conspicuous
yellow-to-orange
inflorescences
and
notable
phytochemical
and
antioxidant
properties.
However,
the
extent
to
which
flower
colour
predicts
phenolic
composition,
flavonoid
abundance,
and
radical-
scavenging
activity
remains
uncertain.
Objectives:
This
critical
narrative
review
examines
the
comparative
pharmacognostic
characteristics,
major
phytochemical
constituents,
and
evidence
concerning
colour-associated
variation
in
total
phenolic
content
(TPC),
total
flavonoid
content
(TFC),
and
2,2-diphenyl-1-
picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) radical-scavenging activity.

Methods:
Relevant
botanical
reviews,
primary
investigations,
and
analytical-method
publications
were
examined
through
targeted
literature searches of accessible scholarly resources.

Key
Findings:
Published
research
on
C.
sulphureus
identifies
chlorogenic
acid,
caffeic
acid,
rutin,
and
quercetin
in
investigated
extracts
alongside
demonstrable
antioxidant
activity
[4].
In
C.
officinalis
,
flavonoids,
phenolic
acids,
carotenoids,
and
triterpenoid
constituents
contribute
to
a
complex
phytochemical
profile
[1,3].
A
study
of
20
C.
officinalis
cultivars
reported
total
flavonoid
contents
ranging
from
0.21%
to
0.68%,
without
establishing
a
conclusive
relationship
between
floret
colour
and
flavonoid
abundance
[6].
Methodological discrepancies—including variations in plant material,
extraction
conditions,
calibration
standards,
and
assay
procedures—
severely restrict quantitative comparisons between published studies,
and direct, standardised comparisons of colour-defined morphs remain
insufficient for both species.

Copyright:
©
Author
2026
by
the
Author.
International
Journal
of
Pharmaceutical
Research
and
Medicinal
Plants
Published
by
Informative Journals
(Jadoun Science Publishing Group India). This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions
of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 1

Conclusions:
Future
investigations
must
combine
authenticated
botanical
material,
instrumental
colour
assessment,
pigment
profiling,validated
spectrophotometric
assays,
and
chromatographic
characterisation to establish reproducible relationships between floral
pigmentation, phytochemical composition, and antioxidant potential.

1. INTRODUCTION

Medicinal
and
aromatic
plants
constitute
vital
sources
of
structurally
diverse
natural
products
used
in
traditional medicine, pharmaceutical research, cosmetics, and functional foods. Their quality depends heavily
on
botanical
identity,
genotype,
environmental
conditions,
developmental
stage,
harvesting
practices,
processing, storage, and chemical composition. Pharmacognostic evaluation is therefore fundamental to the
authentication and standardisation of plant materials, particularly when intended for clinical or commercial
applications [2,5].

The family
Asteraceae includes numerous species valued for their ornamental,
medicinal, nutritional, and
industrial properties. Among these,
Cosmos sulphureus
Cav. and
Calendula officinalis
L. are notable for their
vibrant
yellow-to-orange
inflorescences.
Although
both
species
have
attracted
considerable
interest
as
sources of natural colorants and bioactive constituents, they differ significantly in morphology, traditional
applications, and the extent of their phytochemical documentation.

Cosmos sulphureus
, commonly known as sulphur cosmos, is an annual herb native to Mexico and widely
cultivated
as
an
ornamental
plant.
Its
flowers
have
increasingly
been
investigated
as
potential
sources
of
natural
colorants
and
antioxidant
compounds.
Ortega-Medrano
et
al.
[4]
investigated
ethanolic
and
methanolic
extracts
of
its
leaves
and
flowers,
identifying
phenolic
compounds,
flavonoids,
and
tannins
alongside measurable antioxidant activity. High-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) indicated
the presence of chlorogenic acid, caffeic acid, rutin, and quercetin in the investigated material. These findings
support further exploration of the species' phytochemical diversity, although extract composition cannot be
assumed to remain consistent across distinct populations, plant organs, or extraction protocols.

Calendula officinalis
, commonly known as pot marigold, is an established medicinal and ornamental species
with
extensive
applications
in
traditional
medicine
and
botanical
preparations.
Its
phytochemical
profile
comprises
flavonoids,
phenolic
acids,
carotenoids,
triterpenoids,
and
diverse
secondary
metabolites
[1,3].
Sahu
and
Soni
[3]
have
specifically
examined
the
phytochemical
profiling,
antioxidant
potential,
pharmacognostic
characteristics,
and
biotechnological
significance
of
this
species,
providing
a
robust
framework for integrating botanical authentication with chemical characterisation. Preethi et al. [7] similarly
investigated the in vitro and in vivo antioxidant potential of
C. officinalis
flower extracts.

While
flower
colour
serves
as
a
potentially
useful
phenotypic
marker
for
selecting
plant
material,
its
reliability as an indicator of phytochemical quality requires critical scrutiny. Yellow and orange pigmentation
generally reflects the abundance and composition of carotenoids and accessory pigments. However, phenolic
acids and flavonoids comprise chemically diverse groups whose biosynthesis and accumulation are governed
by
complex
environmental,
developmental,
and
genetic
interactions.
Consequently,
visible
floral
colour
cannot be automatically interpreted as a quantitative proxy for total phenolic content (TPC), total flavonoid
content (TFC), or overall antioxidant capacity.

Direct
empirical
evidence
from
C.
officinalis
illustrates
this
distinction
clearly.
Raal
and
Kirsipuu
[6]
investigated the inflorescences of 20 cultivars originating from eight European countries and cultivated under
uniform
conditions
in
Estonia.
They
reported
total
flavonoid
contents
ranging
from
0.21%
to
0.68%
but
found no conclusive correlation
between total
flavonoid
content and floret
colour. This
demonstrates that
substantial chemical variation can occur within a species independently of visible floral pigmentation.

While
TPC
is
commonly
estimated
using
the
Folin–Ciocalteu
assay,
TFC
is
frequently
assessed
via
aluminium-complexation or related spectrophotometric methods, and DPPH assays quantify the capacity of

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 2

an extract to reduce a stable free radical [8-10]. These methods are valuable screening tools; however, they
measure distinct analytical endpoints and are highly sensitive to solvent composition, calibration standards,
reaction
kinetics,
matrix
interferences,
and
sample
coloration.
Cross-study
comparisons
must
account
for
these methodological discrepancies rather than treating reported values as directly equivalent.

Despite the individual phytochemical data available for both species, a consistent comparative framework
linking pharmacognostic traits, floral colour, TPC, TFC, and DPPH activity remains absent. To address this
gap,
the
objectives
of
this
critical
review
are
to:
(i)
compare
the
botanical
and
pharmacognostic
characteristics
of
C.
sulphureus
and
C.
officinalis
;
(ii)
summarise
their
reported
phenolic,
flavonoid,
and
pigment
constituents;
(iii)
critically
evaluate
the
evidence
concerning
colour-associated
variation
in
TPC,
TFC, and DPPH activity; (iv) examine the methodological factors that restrict cross-study comparisons; and
(v) identify key research priorities for establishing reproducible pharmacognostic and phytochemical quality
standards.

2. MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1. Review Design

This
article
was
prepared
as
a
critical
narrative
review
utilising
a
targeted
literature
search
strategy.
It
synthesises published evidence regarding the pharmacognostic characteristics, phytochemical composition,
floral pigmentation, and antioxidant properties of
C. sulphureus
and
C. officinalis
. It was not designed as an
original experimental investigation or a formally registered systematic review.

2.2. Literature Search Strategy

Accessible
scholarly
databases—including
PubMed,
PubMed
Central,
major
publisher
platforms,
and
relevant bibliographic records—were queried to identify peer-reviewed publications. Search terms combined
the scientific names of both species with keywords spanning pharmacognosy, microscopy, phytochemistry,
flower colour, carotenoids, phenolic compounds, flavonoids, total phenolic content, total flavonoid content,
DPPH, antioxidant activity, extraction protocols, and standardisation.

Representative search strings included:

Primary research articles were prioritised for species-specific quantitative data, while botanical reviews and
methodological
papers
were
utilised
to
contextualize
pharmacognostic
characteristics
and
analytical
limitations. The review also incorporated the published work of Sahu and Soni [3] due to its direct relevance
to the pharmacognostic and phytochemical assessment of
C. officinalis
.

2.3. Eligibility and Evidence Selection

Publications were deemed eligible if they provided substantive data on botanical identity, macroscopic or
microscopic morphology, phytochemical profiles, floral pigmentation, TPC, TFC, or antioxidant activity for
either
target
species.
Methodological
studies
were
included
when
they
clarified
the
interpretation
of
spectrophotometric assays or radical-scavenging measurements. Research involving related Asteraceae taxa
was consulted exclusively to illustrate general biological or analytical principles and was not treated as direct
evidence for
C. sulphureus
or
C. officinalis
. The search was targeted rather than exhaustive.

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 3

2.4. Evidence Extraction and Comparative Assessment

Literature
data
were
categorised
into
five
core
domains:
botanical
authentication/pharmacognosy,
phytochemical composition, pigment-associated floral colour, spectrophotometric TPC/TFC measurements,
and DPPH radical-scavenging activity. Particular attention was paid to plant organs, cultivars/populations,
extraction solvents, analytical methods, reference standards, and reporting units.

2.5. Interpretation of Phytochemical and Antioxidant Assays

To
ensure
rigorous
interpretation,
TPC
values
were
evaluated
based
on
the
specific
assay
protocol
and
reporting basis used in each source. Results expressed as gallic acid equivalents per gram of dry extract were
strictly
distinguished
from
values
reported
per
gram
of
dried
plant
material
or
fresh
weight.
TFC
measurements
were
evaluated
in
light
of
specific
calibration
standards
and
analytical
procedures.
DPPH
outcomes were interpreted according to their respective assay endpoints (percentage inhibition vs.
IC
50
).

2.6. Data Synthesis and Statistical Considerations

Findings were synthesised qualitatively. Given the profound heterogeneity among available studies regarding
biological
materials,
extraction
protocols,
calibration
standards,
reporting
units,
and
assay
endpoints,
no
pooled
effect
sizes,
meta-analyses,
or
novel
statistical
tests
were
performed.
Ethical
approval
was
not
applicable as no primary human or animal experiments were conducted.

3. RESULTS

3.1. Overview of the Available Evidence

Existing literature confirms that both species accumulate secondary metabolites of considerable interest to
natural-product
research
[3,4].
Primary
investigations
by
Ortega-Medrano
et
al.
[4]
provide
valuable
quantitative
and
chromatographic
baseline
data
for
C.
sulphureus
.
Evidence
concerning
C.
officinalis
encompasses cultivar-level assessments of flavonoid content, targeted antioxidant evaluations, and broader
pharmacognostic overviews [1,3,6,7].

As outlined below in Table 1 (ordered newest-first), the current literature lacks standardised, direct head-to-
head comparisons of yellow and orange colour morphs across both species, meaning reported variations in
TPC, TFC, or DPPH activity cannot be attributed to floral pigmentation alone.

Table 1:
Principal publications informing the comparative review.

Reference

Scope

Contribution to the review

[3]
Sahu
and
Soni
(2026)

C. officinalis

Pharmacognostic,
phytochemical,
antioxidant,
and
biotechnological perspective

[9]
Munteanu
and
Apetrei (2021)

Analytical methodology

Review of chemical and cell-based antioxidant assays

[4] Ortega-Medrano et
al. (2023)

C.
sulphureus
leaves
and flowers

Phytochemical
screening,
quantitative
measurements,
HPTLC, and antioxidant assays

[6]
Raal
and
Kirsipuu
(2011)

Twenty
C.
officinalis
cultivars

Cultivar-associated variation in total flavonoid content
and evaluation of floret colour

[7] Preethi et al. (2006)

C.
officinalis
flower
extract

In vitro and in vivo antioxidant investigation

[1] Arora et al. (2013)

Calendula
genus

Botanical,
pharmacognostic,
phytochemical,
and
pharmacological overview

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 4

[8] Blois (1958)

Analytical methodology

Stable-free-radical
method
for
evaluating
antioxidant
activity

[10]
Singleton
and
Rossi (1965)

Analytical methodology

Folin–Ciocalteu colorimetric determination of phenolic
substances

3.2. Comparative Botanical and Pharmacognostic Characteristics

Both species belong to the Asteraceae family and bear capitula, but differences in growth habit, foliage, and
floral morphology support their distinct taxonomic classifications [1,4].
Cosmos sulphureus
is an annual herb
featuring
characteristically
divided
leaves
and
yellow-to-orange
capitula.
Calendula
officinalis
generally
possesses oblong to lanceolate leaves and capitula composed of peripheral ligulate florets and central tubular
florets [1,3,4].

Visual reference morphologies for both targeted taxa are displayed below in Figure 1 and Figure 2.

Figure
1.
Calendula officinalis
L. showing the capitulum inflorescence and ray and disc florets. Original
field photograph captured using a smartphone in Bhilai, Chhattisgarh, India. Plant identification was based
on visible morphological characteristics; formal authentication using herbarium voucher specimens was not
performed. The image is presented as an illustrative field observation rather than an authenticated voucher
specimen (author-captured photograph).

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 5

Figure 2.
Field photographs of
Cosmos sulphureus
Cav. showing orange- and yellow-flowered morphotypes.
(A) Orange-flowered morphotype photographed in Purai village, Durg tehsil and district, Chhattisgarh, India.
(B) Yellow-flowered morphotype photographed in Belhari village, Gunderdehi region, Chhattisgarh, India.
Photographs
were
captured
using
a
smartphone.
Plant
identification
was
based
on
visible
morphological
characteristics; formal authentication using herbarium voucher specimens was not performed. The images are
presented
as
illustrative
field
observations
rather
than
authenticated
voucher
specimens
(author-captured
photographs).

Macroscopic
traits
are
supplemented
by
microscopic
and
physicochemical
parameters
to
ensure
reliable
identification, as summarized in Table 2.

Table 2:
Comparative pharmacognostic characteristics.

Character

Cosmos sulphureus Cav.

Calendula officinalis L.

Family

Asteraceae

Asteraceae

Growth habit

Annual herb, often relatively tall

Annual herb, generally more compact

Leaf morphology

Commonly divided or pinnatisect

Commonly oblong to lanceolate

Inflorescence

Capitulum
with
yellow-to-orange
floral
structures

Capitulum
with
peripheral
ligulate
and
central tubular florets

Common
floral
colours

Yellow, golden-yellow, orange

Yellow
to
orange,
with
cultivar-
dependent variation

Reported
chemical
groups

Phenolic
acids,
flavonoids,
tannins,
terpenoids, and other metabolites

Flavonoids, phenolic acids, carotenoids,
triterpenoids, and other metabolites

Authentication
priorities

Leaf
and
capitulum
morphology,
authenticated
reference
specimens,
chemical fingerprinting

Leaf
and
floret
morphology,
authenticated
reference
specimens,
chemical fingerprinting

Important
source
of
variability

Population,
plant
organ,
and
extraction
solvent

Cultivar,
cultivation
conditions,
floral
tissue, and extraction method

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 6

3.2.1. Microscopic and Physicochemical Evaluation

Microscopy complements macroscopic identification by revealing epidermal structures, stomata, trichomes,
pollen, and floral tissue anatomy. Physicochemical parameters, including moisture content, total ash, acid-
insoluble
ash,
and
extractive
values,
further
aid
in
evaluating
crude
drug
quality.
Furthermore,
chromatographic
fingerprinting—such
as
HPTLC
applied
to
C.
sulphureus
[4]—provides
an
additional
safeguard for chemical consistency.

3.3. Phytochemical Composition of
Cosmos sulphureus

Ortega-Medrano et al. [4] examined ethanolic and methanolic extracts of leaves and flowers from three
C.
sulphureus
populations,
detecting
phenolic
compounds,
flavonoids,
tannins,
and
terpenoids.
HPTLC
confirmed the presence of chlorogenic acid, caffeic acid, rutin, and quercetin. Reported TPC values spanned
from 40.74 to 124.11 mg gallic acid equivalents per gram of dry extract [4].

3.4. Phytochemical Composition of
Calendula officinalis

The chemical profile of
C. officinalis
encompasses flavonoids, phenolic acids, carotenoids, triterpenoids, and
diverse secondary metabolites [1,3]. Carotenoids contribute heavily to visible yellow-to-orange pigmentation,
whereas flavonoids and phenolic acids drive antioxidant behaviour [3]. Raal and Kirsipuu [6] evaluated 20
cultivars
and
reported
total
flavonoid
contents
between
0.21%
and
0.68%,
concluding
that
cultivar
and
growth conditions dictate flavonoid yield independently of floret colour.

3.5. Colour-Associated Variation in Phytochemical Content

While
visible
colour
reflects
pigment
composition,
its
relationship
with
overall
polyphenol
or
flavonoid
content
remains
complex
and
non-linear.
As
detailed
across
Table
3,
evidence
linking
specific
colour
variations directly to quantitative phytochemistry remains sparse for both taxa.

Table 3:
Evidence concerning colour-associated phytochemical variation.

Parameter

Evidence in C. sulphureus

Evidence in C. officinalis

Interpretation

Floral
pigmentation

Yellow-to-orange
pigmentation;
direct
colour-
morph
chemistry
insufficiently characterised

Yellow-to-orange
pigmentation with cultivar-
associated variation

Colour is a phenotype, not
a quantitative assay

Carotenoids

Further
quantitative
pigment
profiling
needed
for
direct
comparison

Recognised
constituents
associated
with
floral
pigmentation

Pigment
profiling
is
necessary
to
explain
visible colour

TPC

Variation among populations,
organs,
and
extracts
reported
[4]

Phenolic
compounds
established,
but
values
depend
heavily
on
study
design [1,3,7]

No
direct
cross-species
ranking is justified

TFC

Flavonoids
identified
and
quantified in extracts [4]

Cultivar-associated
variation reported without a
conclusive
colour
relationship [6]

Colour
alone
is
not
a
validated proxy for TFC

DPPH activity

Activity
reported
in
extracts
[4]

Activity
reported
in
flower
extracts [7]

Results
cannot
be
ranked
reliably
without
comparable
assay
conditions

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 7

Colour–
chemistry
association

Controlled
morph-specific
evidence is insufficient

A
cultivar
study
found
no
conclusive
colour–TFC
relationship [6]

A
major
research
gap
remains

3.6. Total Phenolic Content

The Folin–Ciocalteu procedure remains a standard screening tool, measuring electron-transfer reactions to
produce a colorimetric response relative to a standard [10]. However, because the reagent reacts with diverse
non-phenolic
reducing
species,
TPC
values
must
be
viewed
as
operational
estimates
rather
than
absolute
molecular measurements [9,11].

3.7. Total Flavonoid Content

Spectrophotometric
assays
relying
on
aluminium
complexation
vary
across
reaction
conditions
and
calibration
standards.
Consequently,
values
obtained
via
disparate
protocols
cannot
be
treated
as
directly
interchangeable. Direct chromatographic quantification remains essential for accurate profiling.

3.8. DPPH Radical-Scavenging Activity

The DPPH assay measures free-radical reduction capacity [8]. Both
C. sulphureus
and
C. officinalis
extracts
exhibit
demonstrable
radical-scavenging
activity
[4,7].
However,
intrinsic
sample
coloration,
solvent
interferences,
and
reaction
kinetics
demand
careful
blank
corrections
and
standardized
concentration-
response evaluation [8,9].

3.9. Principal Evidence Gaps

  1. 1.
    Direct
    comparison
    of
    authenticated
    plant
    materials
    under
    matched
    cultivation
    and
    extraction
    conditions;
  2. 2.
    Replicated assessments of predefined colour morphs within each species;
  3. 3.
    Simultaneous measurement of TPC, TFC, DPPH activity, and individual chromatographic markers;
  4. 4.
    Quantitative
    carotenoid
    analysis
    to
    separate
    pigment-associated
    colour
    from
    polyphenol-associated
    activity;
  5. 5.
    Validation of micro-morphological and physicochemical quality markers;
  6. 6.
    Harmonised reporting of extraction yields, moisture content, assay conditions, and dry-weight bases;
  7. 7.
    Rigorous statistical evaluation of instrumental colour parameters against chemical profiles.

4. DISCUSSION

4.1. Comparative Pharmacognostic Significance

Establishing botanical identity through a multi-parameter approach—incorporating macroscopic evaluation,
microscopy, physicochemical limits, and chromatographic fingerprinting—is crucial before undertaking any
comparative phytochemical work. The integration of HPTLC screening with quantitative assays exemplifies
a robust model for crude drug standardisation [1,3,4].

4.2. Flower Colour as a Phytochemical Indicator

The
assumption
that
flower
colour
reliably
predicts
phytochemical
yield
is
challenged
by
botanical
and
biochemical reality. While carotenoids dictate visual appearance, phenolic compounds follow independent
biosynthetic pathways driven by ecological and genetic factors. The absence of a clear colour-to-flavonoid
correlation in
C. officinalis
cultivars [6] strongly discourages relying solely on visual phenotype for industrial
or pharmaceutical selection.

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 8

4.3. Interpretation of TPC and TFC

The variation in TPC reported for
C. sulphureus
demonstrates that sample origin and extraction conditions
heavily influence measured phenolic content [4]. Because the Folin–Ciocalteu and aluminium-complexation
assays suffer from structural selectivity limits and matrix interferences, spectrophotometric results must be
interpreted as method-dependent estimates and reinforced by chromatographic profiling [9,11].

4.4. Relationship Between Phenolic Composition and DPPH Activity

Phenolic acids
and
flavonoids contribute to
antioxidant activity via
electron or hydrogen-atom transfer, a
property dictated by hydroxylation patterns and molecular conjugation. Consequently, higher TPC does not
guarantee proportionally superior DPPH scavenging. Sample blanks and rigorous controls are also vital to
isolate true antioxidant activity from intrinsic pigment absorbance in coloured extracts [8,9].

4.5. Methodological Sources of Variation

Discrepancies
across
published
literature
stem
from
multiple
operational
variables:
biological
material
(genotype, organ, developmental stage), extraction procedures (solvent,
temperature, duration), calibration
standards
(gallic
acid,
quercetin,
rutin),
reporting
basis
(fresh
vs.
dry
mass),
assay
conditions,
and
post-
harvest
handling.
Because
of
these
widespread
methodological
differences,
ranking
species
or
morphs
directly by juxtaposing numbers from disparate studies is scientifically invalid [9,11].

4.6. Implications for Quality Control and Applications

Applications
should
dictate
selection
criteria:
phenolic-rich
extracts
require
validated
TPC
and
chromatography;
flavonoid-focused
uses
require
specific
individual
quantification;
and
natural
colorant
development
depends
primarily
on
carotenoid
profiling
and
instrumental
colourimetry.
A
comprehensive
quality-control
framework
must
integrate
botanical,
macroscopic,
microscopic,
chemical,
and
functional
testing [3].

4.7. Strengths and Limitations of the Review

This
review
successfully
integrates
pharmacognostic
identification,
pigment
chemistry,
and
assay
interpretation
into a cohesive comparative framework.
Its
primary limitation
lies in the scarcity of direct,
head-to-head, colour-controlled studies in the existing literature, coupled with targeted rather than exhaustive
search methodologies.

5. CONCLUSION

The available literature confirms that
Cosmos sulphureus
Cav. and
Calendula officinalis
L. possess distinct
pharmacognostic
traits
and
accumulate
valuable
phytochemicals
with
demonstrable
antioxidant
activity
[1,3,4,6,7]. However, empirical evidence—particularly demonstrated across
C. officinalis
cultivars—proves
that
visible
flower
colour
does
not
reliably
predict
total
flavonoid
abundance
or
phenolic
yield
[6].
At
present, neither flower colour nor heterogeneous published data can establish a definitive superiority in TPC,
TFC,
or
DPPH
activity
between
these
species
or
their
colour
morphs.
Future
research
must
combine
authenticated
botanical
material,
instrumental
colour
measurement,
carotenoid
profiling,
validated
assays,
and
chromatographic
separation
to
determine
whether
floral
phenotype
can
ever
serve
as
a
dependable
quality marker.

6. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors sincerely acknowledge the support, guidance, and encouragement received throughout the course
of this research work. They express their heartfelt gratitude to their parents for their unwavering support,
motivation, and encouragement, which have been invaluable throughout their academic journey.

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 9

The
authors
are
grateful
to
Kamla
Institute
of
Pharmaceutical
Sciences
(KIPS),
Shri
Shankaracharya
Professional
University
(SSPU),
Bhilai,
for
providing
the
necessary
institutional
facilities,
resources,
and
support required to conduct and complete this research successfully.

Furthermore, Mr. Vashvi Kumar Sahu (Author) would like to express his sincere gratitude to his research
guide,
Dr.
Revendra
Parganiha,
Professor,
Kamla
Institute
of
Pharmaceutical
Sciences
(KIPS),
Shri
Shankaracharya
Professional
University
(SSPU),
Bhilai,
for
his
valuable
guidance,
continuous
encouragement, constructive suggestions, and academic support throughout the research work. His expertise,
motivation, and insightful feedback have played a significant role in the successful completion of this study.

Finally, the authors extend their sincere appreciation to everyone who directly or indirectly contributed to the
successful completion of this research work.

7. ETHICS AND OTHER DECLARATIONS

Ethics Statement/Ethical Approval

Not
applicable.
This
article
is
a
narrative
review
of
previously
published
literature
and
does
not
involve
human participants, human biological samples, or experimental animals.

Data Availability Statement

Not applicable. This review does not generate or analyse any new experimental datasets. The information and
evidence
discussed
in
this
manuscript
were
obtained
from
previously
published
literature
and
publicly
available botanical resources.

Informed Consent Statement

Not applicable, as this review does not involve human participants.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Funding

The authors declare that no financial support or external funding was received for the research, authorship, or
publication of this article.

Author Contributions

Mr. Vashvi Kumar Sahu:
Conceptualization, preparation of the original draft, writing, and editing of the
manuscript.
Dr.
Revendra
Parganiha:
Supervision,
technical
guidance,
and
critical
review
of
the
manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript for submission.

REFERENCES:

  1. 1.
    Arora, D; Rani, A and Sharma, A (2013), "A review on phytochemistry and ethnopharmacological
    aspects
    of
    genus
    Calendula
    ",
    Pharmacognosy
    Reviews
    ,
    Vol.
    7
    (14),
    179–187.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.4103/0973-7847.120520
    .
  2. 2.
    Evans, WC (2009),
    Trease and Evans Pharmacognosy
    , 16th edition, Saunders Elsevier, Edinburgh,
    UK, 59-72.
  3. 3.
    Sahu,
    VK
    and
    Soni,
    V
    (2026),
    "Phytochemical
    Profiling
    And
    Antioxidant
    Potential
    Of
    Calendula
    Officinalis
    : A Pharmacognostic And Biotechnological Perspective",
    J. PhytoPharm. Adv. Chem.
    , Vol.
    1 (3), 168–177. DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.66220/3zancg55
    .
  4. 4.
    Ortega-Medrano,
    RJ;
    Ceja-Torres,
    LF;
    Vázquez-Sánchez,
    M;
    Martínez-Ávila,
    GCG
    and
    Medina-
    Medrano,
    JR
    (2023),
    "Characterization
    of
    Cosmos
    sulphureus
    Cav.
    (Asteraceae):
    Phytochemical
Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 10
  1. Screening,
    Antioxidant
    Activity
    and
    Chromatography
    Analysis",
    Plants
    ,
    Vol.
    12
    (4),
    Article
    896.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.3390/plants12040896
    .
  2. 5.
    Heinrich, M; Barnes, J; Gibbons, S and Williamson, EM (2012),
    Fundamentals of Pharmacognosy
    and Phytotherapy
    , 2nd edition, Churchill Livingstone Elsevier, Edinburgh, UK, 112-120.
  3. 6.
    Raal,
    A
    and
    Kirsipuu,
    K
    (2011),
    "Total
    flavonoid
    content
    in
    varieties
    of
    Calendula
    officinalis
    L.
    originating from different countries and cultivated in Estonia",
    Natural Product Research
    , Vol. 25
    (6), 658–662. DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.1080/14786419.2010.528417
    .
  4. 7.
    Preethi,
    KC;
    Kuttan,
    G
    and
    Kuttan,
    R
    (2006),
    "Antioxidant
    potential
    of
    an
    extract
    of
    Calendula
    officinalis
    flowers
    in
    vitro
    and
    in
    vivo",
    Pharmaceutical
    Biology
    ,
    Vol.
    44
    (9),
    691–697.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.1080/13880200601009149
    .
  5. 8.
    Blois, MS (1958), "Antioxidant determinations by the use of a stable free radical",
    Nature
    , Vol. 181
    (4617), 1199–1200. DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.1038/1811199a0
    .
  6. 9.
    Munteanu, IG and Apetrei, C (2021), "Analytical methods used in determining antioxidant activity: A
    review",
    International
    Journal
    of
    Molecular
    Sciences
    ,
    Vol.
    22
    (7),
    Article
    3380.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms22073380
    .
  7. 10.
    Singleton,
    VL
    and
    Rossi,
    JA
    (1965),
    "Colorimetry
    of
    total
    phenolics
    with
    phosphomolybdic-
    phosphotungstic acid reagents",
    American Journal of Enology and Viticulture
    , Vol. 16 (3), 144–158.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.5344/ajev.1965.16.3.144
    .
  8. 11.
    Raposo, F et al. (2024), "A comprehensive and critical review of the unstandardized Folin–Ciocalteu
    assay to determine the total content of polyphenols: The conundrum of the experimental factors and
    method
    validation",
    Talanta
    ,
    Vol.
    272,
    Article
    125771.
    DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2024.125771
    .

How
to
cite
this
article:
Vashvi
Kumar
Sahu,
Revendra
Parganiha,
Comparative
Evaluation
of
Pharmacognostic
Characteristics,
Phytochemical Composition, and Antioxidant Potential of Cosmos sulphureus Cav. and Calendula officinalis L.: A Critical Narrative
Review
on
Flower
Colour
and
Quality
Standardisation
(2026).
International
Journal
of
Pharmaceutical
Research
and
Medicinal
Plants
,
2
(5), i-11,
https://doi.org/10.61280/m6kvm371

Published by:

Informative Journals

Jadoun Science Publishing Group India

Vashvi Kumar Sahu
/
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medicinal Plants
2026, Vol. 2 (5), 01-11
https://informativejournals.com/journal/index.php/Journal_Medicinal_Plants
Page | 11